top of page

Interview with Jack Anderson

cplesley
Nov 13
5 min read

A drawing focused on a woman in an Edwardian style blue silk dress and a black hat, seen against buildings marked United Clubs, a suspension bridge, a safe, two bottles of wine, and two magnifying glasses; cover of Jack Anderson's The Mark of Moriarty

Novels featuring Sherlock Holmes lie thick on the ground—some wonderful, exploring new angles on Arthur Conan Doyle’s creation, and others … well, not so wonderful. But it takes a certain kind of chutzpah to turn the focus away from Sherlock and his equally famous sidekick, John Watson, and instead kill him off while shining the spotlight on the arch-villain Professor James Moriarty. That’s what Jack Anderson decided to do in his Moriarty Mysteries, where Moriarty also acquires a medical sidekick of his own, Doctor Clara Mendel. Read on to find out more from this interview with the author.

Why write a mystery series featuring Professor James Moriarty?

 

Before even thinking of writing this series, I always wondered what it would be like for Professor Moriarty if he had survived the Reichenbach Falls.

 

For Moriarty, dying in the clutches of his most hated enemy is almost a desirable outcome, or at least, a poetic one. Robbing him of that ending, leaving him destitute, thought dead, his empire dismantled by a single man; the question of what he does next always intrigued me.

 

Of course, this is a universe full of mysteries; with a similar force to gravity, Professor Moriarty will be pulled towards some strange intrigue. But I love that he’s not truly a detective; how he investigates, and why he chooses to involve himself, are deeply interesting questions to me.

 

Is your Moriarty more or less the same as Arthur Conan Doyle’s, and if not, how does he differ?

 

Despite being an iconic villain, Moriarty doesn’t appear much in the original stories, in fact, I felt like a forensic investigator as I picked through the canon, trying to lift personality traits like fingerprints.

 

His cleverness is clear throughout the books. In The Final Problem, we get a sense of an explosive temper beneath his intellect. In Valley of Fear, we see an arrogant playfulness, as he hangs a stolen painting under dim light at the back of his office.

 

I took all these aspects to build the Moriarty in my series, someone I hope feels fully realized, but was built on the foundations of the canon.

 

You killed off Sherlock Holmes at Reichenbach Falls, while Moriarty survives and even inherits an obligation. Why was that, and what’s the nature of his obligation?

 

I always found it interesting that, originally, Arthur Conan Doyle intended Sherlock to die at the falls! In a way, these books follow that original timeline, with Moriarty’s survival being the major deviation.

 

I knew I didn’t want to write about Moriarty finding morality at the bottom of the falls. So how to obligate the villain was an interesting question; in my story Holmes sends Moriarty a posthumous letter, which doesn’t seek to reform him, but instead obliges him to answer a far more unsettling question to Moriarty: with talents like yours, is criminality the best you can do?

 

Strangely enough, I still see these books as Sherlock Holmes novels. A great writer once told me a character’s absence, and the hole they leave in the story, tells you as much about them as their presence. Even in his absence, Sherlock Holmes is a critical figure in the series.

 


Drawing of a magnifying glass against a backdrop of broken shards, a skull, a diamond enclosing a circle, a chess piece and two unsheathed swords; cover of Jack Anderson's The Return of Moriarty

In book 1, The Return of Moriarty, James encounters Clara Mendel, who by the second book has become a doctor, specifically what we would now call a psychiatrist. What should potential readers know about her?

 

Clara Mendel, the “Watson” to James Moriarty in my stories, is headstrong, highly intelligent, and self-reliant. On an investigative level, she might have been a better match for Holmes than Dr Watson himself … but in several important respects, she’s no John Watson.

 

Far too comfortable bending the rules, with a talent for deception and obsessed with winning the day, Clara Mendel could be the person who reforms James Moriarty … or she could end up just as bad as him.

 

And what takes Clara to New York in The Mark of Moriarty?

 

At the end of the first book, Clara and Moriarty part ways. It seems like Clara is on an upward track, focused on completing her medical degree and never seeing James Moriarty again.

 

When we meet Clara once more, something has changed. She’s traveled to New York because she expects James Moriarty to be there, obsessed with tracking him down in order to reform the master criminal.

 

Why the incredible u-turn? It’s something Clara can’t even admit to herself. But as anyone might expect; you don’t dig around in a mind like James Moriarty’s and expect to come out unscathed.

 

The Mark of Moriarty, though, opens in Arizona Territory in September 1885. Could you summarize what’s happening there?

 

It’s an ordinary night in a courthouse in Arizona. A warden reads a dime novel as he presides over a perfectly empty jailhouse. His peace is shattered by the courthouse doors blowing open, yet when he shuts them again and returns to the jailhouse … he finds the cells are no longer empty.

 

Someone has closed themselves into his jail, someone so fearful of an external threat that only stone and steel bars might protect them. Our warden draws closer and sees a wretched figure, obsessively scraping one word into the wall; ARCANE, ARCANE, ARCANE.

 

We get very few answers from the warden or his bizarre and traumatized visitor. In fact, this mystery will lie dormant for almost six years, until the strange reappearance of Viola Bellman.

 

The Arcane Society then reappears in an exchange of letters, written in 1891, between Hieronymus Bellman and Dr. John Watson. Could you summarize Bellman’s problem, which eventually becomes Clara Mendel’s and James Moriarty’s problem?

 

Hieronymus Bellman, an old-money resident of Fifth Avenue, Manhattan, has an orphaned niece called Viola. Taking her in from rural Massachusetts, Mr. Bellman feared Viola would damage his reputation in the city. Instead, Viola Bellman became a lauded celebrity, elevating the Bellman name to the top of New York Society.

 

After a scandal forced Viola to flee the city, the young woman faded from Manhattan’s consciousness. Until, in January 1891, Viola returned in impossible circumstances; seemingly materializing in a snowy alleyway, with no footprints around her, refusing to speak and clutching a bible with a strange inscription; THE ARCANE SOCIETY OF NEW YORK HOLDS CLOSE THE FORTUNE YOU SEEK.

 

As Viola’s impossible return fills the gossip rags, Mr. Bellman contacts Sherlock Holmes. Holmes perishes at Reichenbach before he can investigate. James Moriarty seemingly travels to New York to complete a case his rival couldn’t solve, and Clara journeys there for a simpler reason … to find James Moriarty.

 

And what can you say about the Arcane Society? How does it want to be seen?

 

A funny thing I discovered in my research, in 1892, the New York City Directory had a “Secret Societies” section. It’s fair to say most “secret societies” weren’t really under the radar; after all, having a secret isn’t as fun if no one knows you have one.

 

The Arcane Society of New York, however, was never heard of until Viola Bellman escaped it. A truly secret society, its meeting place, membership, its very existence seemingly hidden from everyone outside its walls.

 

Although their motives are as clandestine as they are, one thing is clear … they don’t take kindly to being discovered.

 

Will there be more Moriarty novels, and if so, can you tell us anything about book 3?

 

I would love to continue with the Moriarty series! Unlike Holmes, who spent most of the canon in, or around, London, Professor Moriarty is in the opposite situation. He’s presumed dead but an infamous figure in the United Kingdom, meaning he can travel everywhere in the world except for his homeland.

 

Researching and bringing international locations to life, sending the Professor and Clara against master thieves and serial killers, and further exploring the fractured mind of James Moriarty would be a dream come true! 


A bearded young man with dark hair, wearing a slightly puffy red jacket with a black shirt underneath; head shot of Jack Anderson

Jack Anderson, a UK based writer of horror and mystery fiction, is the author of The Grief Doctor—published by Raven Books in 2024 and the Moriarty Mystery series with Crooked Lane Books. The Mask of Moriarty is his latest novel.

  • Facebook Classic
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest App Icon

© 2015 by C. P. Lesley. All rights reserved.

bottom of page